Truth Value

I used to lie a lot. For most of my elementary school education I was at an British international school. After 6th grade, however, my dad transferred me to a local Hong Kong school. While the school was still mostly taught in English, I was simply unused to the style of education and the amount of tedious work. My bad Chinese, which was the reason I transferred (to patch up) in the first place, was a particular burden. Looking back, I can heardly believe what I did back then: pretending to have headaches, on-purposely turning in the wrong notebook, finishing only half the homework before turning it in.

Luckily, after two and half years of what is easily the worst years of my life, I transferred to an American international school, which is ultimately why I'm in the US now. While I don't do the same tricks anymore, I still retain the "training" I got from that period. I am still a very smooth liar. I can maintain the complex web of information flow most of the time, making sure I don't tell the wrong person the wrong thing. Sometimes, I still lie before I have thought the situation through.

Since entering high school my memories of those deliquent years have faded a lot. I never keep contact with my friends from that school, and memories of the physical location and the times I spent there are generic. Becoming more and more a scientist and philosopher, I've often held knowing the truth above all else. A few recent events, though, have made me ponder the value of truth. Specifically, under what circumstances is it okay for one to lie?

Consider these situations:
  • Someone very close to you is in the hospital. You just learned from the doctor that they have some terminal illness. Would you tell them that they are dying, or would you lie and say everything will be okay?
  • You have had a crush on someone for a long time. You spend a lot of time with them, but they don't find you romantically attractive. Do you risk rejection and tell them your feelings, or do you hide it or worse, lie saying you don't feel the way you do (anymore)?
  • Someone close to you is in what you think is a cult. There is no danger from being in the cult, and they are very comfortable in this organization. You have just found evidence that their beliefs are entirely wrong. Do you tell them and watch their world collapse, or do you let them live happily in ignorance?
It's hard to say what truth is being weighed against in the first case. There is no obvious benefit from telling or not telling the truth. In the second case, truth is being weighed against your personal happiness; in the third case, against your friend's personal happiness.

If I was the "other person" in all three cases, I would unhesitantly prefer to know the truth than be left in the dark. To me personally I see no good coming out of ignorance. Happiness can be found again, and only in knowing what is actually out there can you make the correct decision.

Being the person holding the truth, though, makes things a little different. In the first and third case, I would still tell the truth. I can see this as selfishness - when only other people's happiness is involved I tell the truth. For the second case, I do not fear the rejection so much as losing what I already have. People tend to pay more to prevent loss than to gain the same amount.

Perhaps it might be more prudent to ask first whether they would like to hear the truth. In the first case it wouldn't matter - it is clear what the lie would be about, and that is tantamount to telling the truth. In the second and third case though, asking first is a possible strategy. "I have something to tell you. You may not like it, but I would like to offer you the truth. If you don't want to hear it, I won't tell you, but I wanted to let you know that I didn't deliberately hide it from you."

Admittedly, I don't do that all the time. It takes a lot of integrity and courage to do so, more than what I have. More often than not, I will withhold the truth, and not let them be aware I even know something. Instead, I will do something to let them discover the truth themselves, or work to have their mind made up first, before revealing anything.

But isn't withholding the truth still lying?

1 comment :

  1. Truth sucks ass. It's subjective. I believe in truth only so far as mathematics and continuous scales. Categorization, on the other hand, complicates things. With categories, there can be no absolute truth because categories don't really exist in reality. Ie there are no apples because each 'apple' is different.

    When it comes to human emotions and morals, there is definitely no truth. Being friends with someone doesn't always mean that you are always be friendly towards them. So in a way it could be a lie to tell someone that you like them, because you don't always like them. I suppose it wouldn't then be a lie to tell someone that you sometimes like them. :D

    As for the three scenarios. As someone who wants to puruse a medical career, I would inform the patient. It is their right to know what is happening to their own bodies. That way they can try to prepare themselves as well as those around them. It may also help in case there is an emergency and another doctor will have to take charge of the situation. It would definitely help if the patient is aware.

    For the second situation, I have withheld things from so many people for the simple fact that I know my attraction to any one person never lasts long. I think the shortest was three days, the longest maybe five months. In any case, since I knew it was fleeting, there didn't seem to be a point in telling the people.

    For the third, if you mean a 'cult' in the sense that their beliefs have consequences for other people (ie they are a danger to others) then I would most definitely do my best to disuade them. If you mean they are religious, then I would not lie about my own beliefs, but if their faith is strong enough despite my words, then what can I do? It is their right to believe what they want, so long as it doesn't hurt anyone else.